Projecting J.T. Compher’s next contract

Written in

by

Following the best season of his career, Compher is due for a raise in free agency.


Player Overview

Originally selected 35th overall by the Buffalo Sabres, Compher was part of the package which was sent to Colorado in the 2015 Ryan O’Reilly trade. From there, Compher earned a full-time NHL role with the Avalanche in 2017 and hasn’t looked back.

For five seasons between 2017-18 and 2021-22, Compher posted extremely consistent numbers with the Avalanche, managing between 30-40 points per 82 in almost every season. He also suited up for all 20 of the team’s playoff games in 2022, on route to a Stanley Cup win.

Coming off the Cup win, Compher took another step this season. He got a great opportunity with Colorado after Nazem Kadri left in free agency last summer, and the team was left without a true second-line center.

His ice time increased as a result, jumping to over 20 minutes per game, from only around 16 minutes the previous year, and he managed 52 points, which was by far the highest production of his career.

NHL Standard career statistics
Scoring Goals Assists Shots
Season Age Tm Lg GP G A PTS +/- PIM EV PPG SHG GWG EV PP SH SOG SPCT TSA TOI ATOI FOW FOL FO% BLK HIT TK GV Awards
2016-17 21 COL NHL 21 3 2 5 0 4 2 1 0 1 2 0 0 30 10.0 59 314 14:56 78 86 47.6 21 11 6 8
2017-18 22 COL NHL 69 13 10 23 -29 20 7 4 2 3 7 3 0 131 9.9 231 1104 16:00 273 332 45.1 65 45 16 13
2018-19 23 COL NHL 66 16 16 32 -8 31 9 4 3 3 11 5 0 118 13.6 197 1153 17:29 301 311 49.2 59 33 23 23
2019-20 24 COL NHL 67 11 20 31 9 18 10 1 0 3 13 4 3 106 10.4 179 1122 16:45 341 374 47.7 60 36 22 21
2020-21 25 COL NHL 48 10 8 18 10 19 9 1 0 2 7 1 0 47 21.3 88 682 14:13 216 255 45.9 38 32 16 10
2021-22 26 COL NHL 70 18 15 33 6 25 13 4 1 0 13 2 0 102 17.6 199 1143 16:19 338 319 51.4 55 31 26 18
2022-23 27 COL NHL 82 17 35 52 8 33 12 5 0 3 26 9 0 154 11.0 255 1684 20:32 813 852 48.8 82 37 28 28
Career 7 yrs NHL 423 88 106 194 -4 150 62 20 6 15 79 24 3 688 12.8 1208 7202 17:02 2360 2529 48.3 380 225 137 121

Compher can use his speed to play with a lot of intensity in his game and be hard on pucks, but it remains to be seen as to whether he can sustain his production to work out as a long-term, second-line center. He’s coming off a four-year deal, which paid him $3.5M per year.


What We Know


Comparables

Below, we take a look at what Compher’s deal could look like at different lengths. For more information on the stats/tables used below, including how the payment rate in projections is determined, visit the About the Site page.

For the comparable contracts, we’ll be looking at centers who were between 26 and 30 years old by Dec. 31 in the first year of their contract.

6 YEARS

Six years would likely be the maximum term given to Compher. Typically, centers getting seven or eight-year deals would have much higher production, and Compher just doesn’t fit into the same category.

That said, six years is possible.

PlayerAgeFirst Year
of Contract
Signing
Year
G&P/82
Career
G&P/82
Mid
Point
Cap HitOn
$83.5M
Cap
Payment
Rate
Projection
J.T. Compher28202317-52
(82GP)
17-38
(423GP)
17-45
Phillip Danault2820218-37
(53GP)
12-42
(392GP)
10-40$5.50M
6 years
$5.63M
6 years
1.41$6.33M
6 years
Brock Nelson28201925-53
(82GP)
21-41
(480GP)
23-47$6.00M
6 years
$6.15M
6 years
1.31$5.89M
6 years
David Krejci29201519-71
(80GP)
18-62
(504GP)
19-67$7.25M
6 years
$8.48M
6 years
1.27$5.70M
6 years
Mikael Backlund29201814-48
(58GP)
16-41
(519GP)
15-45$5.35M
6 years
$5.62M
6 years
1.25$5.62M
6 years
**Kyle Turris29201828-59
(89GP)
21-48
(544GP)
25-54$6.00M
6 years
$6.30M
6 years
1.17$5.25M
6 years
Jean-Gabriel Pageau28202033-55
(60GP)
17-35
(428GP)
25-45$5.00M
6 years
$5.12M
6 years
1.14$5.12M
6 years
Nazem Kadri26201618-49
(76GP)
20-50
(326GP)
19-50$4.50M
6 years
$5.15M
6 years
1.03$4.64M
6 years
*Jonathan Marchessault28201835-87
(35GP)
27-55
(157GP)
31-71$5.00M
6 years
$5.25M
6 years
0.74$3.33M
6 years
*Midseason signing – Signing Year stats calculated from games played in season where deal was signed, up to the point of signing.
** Deal signed early into season – stats from that year before signing, as well as previous year are combined for Signing Year stats

We know Compher won’t be up as high as Danault’s deal would project, given Danault was entering free agency at the time of signing where he was coming off a Stanley Cup Finals appearance and had established himself as one of the best defensive centers in the NHL.

At the same time, he wouldn’t be as low as Marchessault’s payment rate would suggest. Marchessault had a massive singing year which would skew his production mid-point and as a result, the payment rate is lower than it typically would be for others. Meanwhile, Kadri’s contract also projects a deal for Compher that’s lower than almost any other comparable would suggest.

From the other five comps though, we get a range of $5.12M to $5.89M. It does get a little bit more difficult to determine exactly where Compher would fall within that range, though. I would predict him to be on the lower end of the range, given players who have a much better signing year production than their career production typically aren’t paid at the same rate as players who have had consistent production.

Jean-Gabriel Pageau and Mikael Backlund each had the same production mid point as Compher and their deals had the projection on the middle-to-low end of the range, at $5.12M and $5.62M respectively. This seems to be the most likely range, likely to come in somewhere between the figures.


5 YEARS

Five years may be the most likely term for Compher. If you look at centers around his age who have signed five-year deals in the past, the majority have similar production.

PlayerAgeFirst Year
of Contract
Signing
Year
G&P/82
Career
G&P/82
Mid
Point
Cap HitOn
$83.5M
Cap
Payment
Rate
Projection
J.T. Compher28202317-52
(82GP)
17-38
(423GP)
17-45
Brandon Sutter27201622-34
(80GP)
16-31
(495GP)
19-33$4.38M
5 years
$5.01M
5 years
1.52$6.83M
5 years
Artem Anisimov28201611-43
(52GP)
17-38
(412GP)
14-41$4.55M
5 years
$5.20M
5 years
1.27$5.71M
5 years
Adam Henrique29201924-51
(81GP)
23-47
(512GP)
24-49$5.83M
5 years
$5.97M
5 years
1.22$5.48M
5 years
Andrew Copp28202224-60
(72GP)
14-34
(483GP)
19-47$5.63M
5 years
$5.70M
5 years
1.21$5.45M
5 years
Carl Soderberg30201513-44
(82GP)
15-48
(161GP)
14-46$4.75M
5 years
$5.55M
5 years
1.21$5.43M
5 years
*Lars Eller29201817-43
(53GP)
14-30
(576GP)
16-37$3.50M
5 years
$3.68M
5 years
0.99$4.48M
5 years
Ryan Strome29202223-60
(74GP)
17-47
(621GP)
20-54$5.00M
5 years
$5.06M
5 years
0.94$4.23M
5 years
*Midseason signing – Signing Year stats calculated from games played in season where deal was signed, up to the point of signing.

From the five-year comparbales, we get a range of $4.2M to $6.8M for Compher’s next contract. However, there are visible outliers, with Sutter’s deal as a clear overpayment, projecting a deal that no other comparable is, while Lars Eller and Ryan Strome would both have Compher too low, below $4.5M.

Four of the seven comps would have Compher between a very defined range of $5.43M to $5.71M, and this seems to be realistic. Specifically, Andrew Copp’s deal from last summer acts as an excellent comparable.

Copp was the same age, had similar NHL experience and had very similar production, where he posted much larger numbers in his signing year than over his career, but both totals were quite close to Compher’s stats. His $5.63M deal, projecting a $5.45M contract for Compher, is a solid range.


4 YEARS

Four years is likely the shortest term we’d see for Compher’s deal, and there really aren’t many comparables for it, in terms of centers of his age and production signing at that length.

PlayerAgeFirst Year
of Contract
Signing
Year
G&P/82
Career
G&P/82
Mid
Point
Cap HitOn
$83.5M
Cap
Payment
Rate
Projection
J.T. Compher28202317-52
(82GP)
17-38
(423GP)
17-45
Paul Stastny29201429-69
(71GP)
24-70
(538GP)
27-70$7.00M
4 years
$8.47M
4 years
1.21$5.45M
4 years
Nick Bonino29201718-38
(80GP)
15-38
(407GP)
17-38$4.10M
4 years
$4.56M
4 years
1.20$5.40M
4 years
Pavel Zacha2620-2310-49
(82GP)
14-39
(428GP)
12-44$4.75M
4 years
$4.75M
4 years
1.08$4.85M
4 years
Boone Jenner29202216-34
(41GP)
19-37
(530GP)
18-36$3.75M
4 years
$3.80M
4 years
1.06$4.75M
4 years

Of the four comparables, we see two slightly different ranges. Stastny and Bonino would have Compher right around $5.4M on a four-year deal, while Zacha and Jenner’s deals would put Compher at $4.8M.

On one hand, Bonino was coming off back-to-back Stanley Cups, so his payment rate was likely inflated. Plus, Compher didn’t have anywhere close to the same production as Stastny. At the same time, Compher would likely be offered a five-year deal (even if the cap hit isn’t as high on that term as projected), so if he’s going to take a four-year contract, the cap hit would have to be high.

While a four-year deal may not take Compher up to that $5.40M mark, I’d still expect him to be on the upper end of this range.


Projection

Five years remains the most likely outcome for Compher’s next contract.

TermProjected Cap HitMaximumMinimum
5 Years$5.50M$6.00M$5.00M

That said, we could also see the deal go as long as six years or as short as four years.

TermProjected Cap HitMaximumMinimum
6 Years$5.25M$6.00M$5.00M
4 Years$5.25M$5.75M$4.75M

Tags

Leave a comment