Projecting Semyon Varlamov’s next contract

Written in

by

Varlamov could take on a larger role elsewhere, rather than returning to the Islanders as Ilya Sorokin’s backup.


Player Overview

Semyon Varlamov first entered the NHL with the Washington Capitals, after being selected 23rd overall in the 2006 NHL Draft.

At just 20 years old, he was already playing a key role with Washington in the team’s 2009 playoff run, which fell short against Sidney Crosby’s Pittsburgh Penguins. In the next two years though, Varlamov found himself fighting for starts with the likes of Jose Theodore, Michal Neuvirth and Braden Holtby. As a result, he was dealt to the Colorado Avalanche in 2011 for both a first and second-round pick.

With the Avalanche, Varlamov quickly emerged as the team’s starter. He played about 70 percent of Colorado’s games from 2011-12 until 2015-16 and posted a .917 save percentage across 265 games in that time. He also finished second in Vezina Trophy voting in 2014, as well as fourth in Hart Trophy voting.

Varlamov’s final three years in Colorado did see him take on a bit of a smaller workload, and he had a really tough time in Colorado’s disastrous 2016-17 year, posting an .898 save percentage in just 24 games. However, Varlamov did rebound for the 2017-18 and 2018-19 seasons for about 50 games per season and managed better numbers.

That marked the end of his eight-year tenure with Colorado though, and in 2019, Varlamov signed with the New York Islanders.

Upon joining New York, Varlamov played as a part of a tandem with Thomas Greiss, taking on the bulk of the workload. However, it was the 2021 COVID season where Varlamov shined, posting a .929 save percentage in 36 games, earning some Vezina votes again, this time resulting in a fifth-place finish.

Over the past two years though, Varlamov has taken a back seat with the Islanders, due to the emergence of Ilya Sorokin. Varlamov has started just 51 games over the past two seasons combined, posting a steady .912 save percentage.

NHL Standard career statistics
Goalie Stats Scoring
Season Age Tm Lg GP GS W L T/O GA SA SV SV% GAA SO MIN QS QS% RBS GA%- GSAA adjGAA GPS G A PTS PIM Awards
2008-09 20 WSH NHL 6 5 4 0 1 13 159 146 .918 2.37 0 329 4 .800 1 2.56 1.1 0 0 0 2
2009-10 21 WSH NHL 26 23 15 4 6 65 718 653 .909 2.55 2 1527 11 .478 3 102 -1.3 2.87 4.2 0 1 1 0
2010-11 22 WSH NHL 27 25 11 9 5 58 759 701 .924 2.23 2 1560 18 .720 2 88 8.1 2.54 5.5 0 0 0 2
2011-12 23 COL NHL 53 52 26 24 3 136 1564 1428 .913 2.59 4 3151 28 .538 10 101 -0.8 3.07 9.4 0 1 1 2
2012-13 24 COL NHL 35 33 11 21 3 98 1007 909 .903 3.02 3 1950 12 .364 7 110 -9.3 3.57 5.1 0 1 1 0
2013-14 25 COL NHL 63 60 41 14 6 146 2013 1867 .927 2.41 2 3640 44 .733 4 84 27.5 2.82 15.5 0 3 3 2 AS-2,Hart-4,Vezina-2
2014-15 26 COL NHL 57 57 28 20 8 141 1791 1650 .921 2.56 5 3307 33 .579 6 92 11.9 3.05 12.2 0 0 0 4
2015-16 27 COL NHL 57 57 27 25 3 148 1714 1566 .914 2.81 2 3159 25 .439 10 101 -2.1 3.36 9.9 0 0 0 6
2016-17 28 COL NHL 24 23 6 17 0 76 745 669 .898 3.38 1 1348 11 .478 5 118 -11.5 3.92 3.1 0 1 1 0
2017-18 29 COL NHL 51 47 24 16 6 128 1595 1467 .920 2.68 2 2861 28 .596 5 91 12.0 2.89 10.2 0 0 0 2
2018-19 30 COL NHL 49 49 20 19 9 136 1496 1360 .909 2.87 2 2839 25 .510 9 101 -1.2 3.06 8.2 0 0 0 2
2019-20 31 NYI NHL 45 39 19 14 6 110 1278 1168 .914 2.62 2 2517 21 .538 4 95 5.6 2.79 7.8 0 0 0 0
2020-21 32 NYI NHL 36 35 19 11 4 72 1020 948 .929 2.04 7 2117 26 .743 4 77 22.0 2.21 8.4 0 1 1 2 AS-6,Vezina-5
2021-22 33 NYI NHL 31 29 10 17 2 87 978 891 .911 2.91 2 1792 16 .552 3 96 4.0 2.98 5.8 0 0 0 0
2022-23 34 NYI NHL 23 22 11 9 2 60 689 629 .913 2.70 2 1335 14 .636 4 91 6.0 2.74 4.5 0 0 0 0
8 yrs COL NHL 389 378 183 156 38 1009 11925 10916 .915 2.72 21 22255 206 .545 56 97 27.8 3.14 73.5 0 6 6 18
4 yrs NYI NHL 135 125 59 51 14 329 3965 3636 .917 2.54 13 7761 77 .616 15 89 39.8 2.67 26.5 0 1 1 2
3 yrs WSH NHL 59 53 30 13 12 136 1636 1500 .917 2.39 4 3416 33 .623 6 93 9.8 2.69 10.8 0 1 1 4
Career 15 yrs NHL 583 556 272 220 64 1474 17526 16052 .916 2.65 38 33432 316 .568 77 95 85.7 2.98 110.8 0 8 8 24

Entering free agency, Varlamov’s priorities could really dictate where he signs and what his deal could look like. There’s no doubt Varlamov is still capable of playing more than 25 or 30 games, and this occurring in New York was just due to the team benefitting from having one of the best goalies in the world as their starter.

Varlamov could remain in New York, but if he wanted a larger role (and likely more money), there are other teams around the league who could certainly use him in a larger capacity than the Islanders have recently.


What We Know

  • Varlamov noted he does hope to remain with the Islanders.
  • Pierre LeBrun said it wouldn’t surprise him if a two-year extension was reached for Varlamov.

Comparables

Below, we take a look at contract projections for different possible terms. For more information on the stats/tables used in the projection, visit the About the Site page.

Note: The comparables used are goalies who signed their contract at a similar age. All ages listed are related to how old the player was by Dec. 31 in the first year of their contract.

3 YEARS

It’s unlikely we’d see Varlamov reach a three-year deal, but goalies around the same age have managed to find one in recent years.

PlayerAge at first
year of deal
First Year
Of Deal
SV%/GP in
Signing Year
% of Games
Started in
Signing Year
SV%/GP
over Career
ContractAdjusted to
$83.5M cap
Semyon Varlamov352023913
(23GP)
28%916
(583GP)
Ryan Miller342014918
(59GP)
72%915
(559GP)
$6.00M
3 years
$7.26M
3 years
Marc-Andre Fleury352019927
(46GP)
56%913
(737GP)
$7.00M
3 years
$7.13M
3 years
Craig Anderson342015911
(53GP)
65%915
(371GP)
$4.20M
3 years
$4.91M
3 years
Cam Talbot332020919
(26GP)
37%915
(314GP)
$3.67M
3 years
$3.76M
3 years
Anton Khudobin342020930
(30GP)
43%919
(218GP)
$3.33M
3 years
$3.41M
3 years
Carter Hutton332018931
(32GP)
39%915
(138GP)
$2.75M
3 years
$2.89M
3 years

There are a few major factors to consider with this though. First Varlamov is already 35 years old, while most of the comparable goalies signing three-year deals were only 33 or 34 years old in their contract year. It may not seem like much, but once a player gets into their mid-30s, each year does count.

The other factor is that Varlamov played just 28 percent of his team’s games this past season, which is lower than any other comparable listed.

The only way it seems possible that Varlamov would get a three-year contract is if he took a very reduced price for it, likely at a lower cap hit than any other deal listed here.


2 YEARS

Two years could be the most likely term for Varlamov’s contract.

PlayerAge at first
year of deal
First Year
Of Deal
SV%/GP in
Signing Year
% of Games
Started in
Signing Year
SV%/GP
over Career
ContractAdjusted to
$83.5M cap
Semyon Varlamov352023913
(23GP)
28%916
(583GP)
**Pekka Rinne372019929
(66GP)
72%919
(574GP)
$5.00M
2 years
$5.12M
2 years
Craig Anderson372018926
(40GP)
49%916
(506GP)
$4.75M
2 years
$4.99M
2 years
Jonathan Bernier332021914
(24GP)
43%913
(394GP)
$4.13M
2 years
$4.23M
2 years
Corey Crawford362020917
(40GP)
49%918
(488GP)
$3.90M
2 years
$4.00M
2 years
Jake Allen332023905
(35GP)
43%911
(353GP)
$3.85M
2 years
$3.85M
2 years
Thomas Greiss342020913
(31GP)
44%915
(282GP)
$3.60M
2 years
$3.69M
2 years
Marc-Andre Fleury382022908
(56GP)
68%913
(939GP)
$3.50M
2 years
$3.54M
2 years
Jaroslav Halak332018908
(54GP)
66%916
(449GP)
$2.75M
2 years
$2.89M
2 years
James Reimer332021906
(22GP)
39%913
(385GP)
$2.25M
2 years
$2.31M
2 years
Mike Smith392021923
(32GP)
57%912
(642GP)
$2.20M
2 years
$2.25M
2 years
Ryan Miller372017914
(54GP)
66%915
(709GP)
$2.00M
2 years
$2.23M
2 years
** Deal signed early into season – stats from that year before signing, as well as previous year are combined for Signing Year stats.

Again though, typically goalies who had such a minimal role in their signing year didn’t end up with a two-year deal above $2M. It’s also tough to compare him against goalies who signed their deal as a starter.

That said, we can get a bit more of a range between the contracts for Bernier, Allen, Greiss and Reimer, who all played less than 45 percent of their team’s game in their signing year.

Bernier’s $4.2M adjusted cap hit represents the upper range of what Varlamov could make, but that still seems highly unlikely. The signing year stats were about the same, but the discrepancy in games played should push Varlamov well below that range.

At the same time, Varlamov should be above Reimer’s $2.3M adjusted cap hit. Reimer also played under 40 percent of his team’s games, but did it with a much lower save percentage.

So the more realistic range is between about $2.3M and Allen’s $3.9M.

Varlamov did notably have better stats than Allen, but the same save percentage as Greiss. Again though, he played a far lower percentage of his team’s games in his signing year, so he shouldn’t be that to close $3.5M, as those contracts came in.

So chances are, Varlamov ends up between $2.5M and $3M on a two-year deal.


1 YEAR

Term on a contract should be important for Varlamov, given his age. That said, we don’t know how long he intends to continue playing, so a one-year contract is always possible.

PlayerAge at first
year of deal
First Year
Of Deal
SV%/GP in
Signing Year
% of Games
Started in
Signing Year
SV%/GP
over Career
ContractAdjusted to
$83.5M cap
Semyon Varlamov352023913
(23GP)
28%916
(583GP)
*Jimmy Howard352019908
(48GP)
67%914
(516GP)
$4.00M
1 year
$4.10M
1 year
Cam Ward342018906
(43GP)
52%909
(668GP)
$3.00M
1 year
$3.15M
1 year
Jaroslav Halak352020919
(31GP)
44%916
(520GP)
$2.25M
1 year
$2.31M
1 year
Mike Smith372019898
(42GP)
51%912
(571GP)
$2.00M
1 year
$2.05M
1 year
Mike Smith382020902
(39GP)
56%911
(610GP)
$1.50M
1 year
$1.54M
1 year
*Deal signed mid-season – stats from season before the point of signing are used.

Looking at the range of comparables, Smith signed both of his deals while quite a bit older and after a fairly poor season. So Varlamov’s range is likely Halak’s $2.3M adjusted cap hit or above.

Chances are though, if Varlamov is taking a one-year deal, it’s because it’ll come with a higher cap hit from a team other than the Islanders. He’s likely to be offered a two-year deal by someone, so it would probably take a higher cap hit, around $3M or more, for him to opt for that rather than a deal with more term. It’s possible a team could see him as a 1B goalie and pay him accordingly for one year, but a two-year deal still seems more likely.


Projection

Two years remains by far the most likely term for Varlamov’s next contract.

TermProjected Cap hitMaximum Cap HitMinimum Cap Hit
2 years$2.75M$3.50M$2.25M

That said, a one-year deal or even a three-year deal remain possible as well.

TermProjected Cap hitMaximum Cap HitMinimum Cap Hit
1 year$3.00M$3.15M$2.50M
3 years$2.33M$3.33M$2.00M

Tags

Leave a comment